If you were Catholic and had your choice, would you choose a Catholic town?
A former marine who was raised by nuns and made a fortune selling pizza has embarked on a £230m plan to build the first town in America to be run according to strict Catholic principles . . .
Tom Monaghan, the founder of the Domino’s Pizza chain, has stirred protests from civil rights activists by declaring that Ave Maria’s pharmacies will not be allowed to sell condoms or birth control pills. The town’s cable television network will carry no X-rated channels . . .
The land on the western edge of the Everglades swamp will eventually house up to 30,000 people, with 5,000 students living on the university campus . . .
The Florida developers managing the project claim more than 7,000 people have already expressed interest in buying homes in the town. Retailers and other businesses are reportedly close to leasing 60% of the intended commercial space.
So what’s the big deal? Personally, I would not choose to live there (mostly because I don’t care for Florida weather,) but why does it matter if others would? I also would not choose to live on a kibbutz in Israel, but I don’t mind if others do. The way I read it, no one is being held prisoner in the town, but it is being provided as a convenience for those who wish to raise their children (or maintain themselves) in a certain cultural atmosphere. Religion-based housing discrimination is, of course, against the law, but so what if the local businesses are required to uphold certain values. So what if the Ave Maria pharmacy won’t sell you contraceptives? Florida has thousands of pharmacies. So what if the Ave Maria movie house won’t show porn? Florida has hundreds of movie theaters.
Americans already segregate themeselves into little cultural bastions (“Chinatown,” “Greektown,” etc.) and common community values are observed within each. Heck, some people actually pay for the privilege of living in developments with ridiculous yard-maintenance rules and homeowner’s associations. How is this any different?